Starling Bank and Mettle by NatWest are both well‑known digital providers in the UK. The former is a traditional business account with a digital‑first experience. The latter, backed by NatWest, focuses on simplicity and admin support for small businesses, particularly sole traders.
This guide compares Mettle and Starling across features, fees, regulation, and which UK businesses each account is best suited to.
Starling vs Mettle: At a Glance Comparison
Starling | Mettle | |
Account model | Fully licensed bank | E-Money Institution (EMI) |
Core focus | Full business banking | Simple banking, admin support |
Typical users | Limited companies, SMEs | Sole traders, micro‑businesses |
Monthly fees | Free | Free |
Cash deposits | Via Post Office (fees apply) | Via Post Office (fees apply) |
Lending | Available | Not available |
FSCS protection | Yes, up to £120,000 | Yes, up to £120,000 |
Starling vs Mettle: Fee Comparison
Fee | Starling | Mettle |
|---|---|---|
Monthly account fee | £0 | £0 |
Optional paid add-ons | Accounting Plus (VAT tools) £7/month; euro account £2/month; Bulk Payments £7/month | Mettle+ (quotes, invoice reminders) £4/month |
Accounting software | Starling Accounting Essentials free, including Making Tax Digital for Income Tax tool | FreeAgent included if you make one transaction a month |
UK Faster Payments, Direct Debits, standing orders | Free | Free |
CHAPS payments | £20 per payment | Not available |
Receiving payments in GBP | Free | Free |
Sending international payments | 0.4% conversion fee plus exchange rate | Not available |
Receiving international payments | No fixed fee; converted at Starling’s inbound rate, which includes a margin | £4 per payment over £10, plus 1.5% if converted to GBP |
Cash deposits (Post Office) | 0.7% of the amount, minimum £3 | £2.75 per deposit (£10 to £500 per deposit, £500 a day, £23,000 a year) |
UK cash withdrawals | Free at cash machines; 50p at a Post Office counter | £1 per withdrawal |
Replacement card | £5 (£10 if sent abroad) | £5 if lost or damaged; free if stolen |
Arranged overdraft | Limited companies only: annual fee of 1.75% of the limit (minimum £50) plus interest. Not offered to sole traders | Not available |
Interest on balances | None on the current account | Interest on one savings pot |
FSCS protection | Up to £120,000 | Up to £120,000 |
What That Costs in Practice
Scenario | Starling | Mettle |
|---|---|---|
Pay in £300 cash | £3.00 | £2.75 |
Pay in £1,000 cash | £7.00 (one deposit) | £5.50 (two £500 deposits on separate days) |
Pay in £20,000 cash over a year, in £500 deposits | £140 | £110 |
Receive a £1,000 payment in euros | No fixed fee; cost depends on the exchange rate margin | £19 (£4 fixed + 1.5%) |
Pay a supplier abroad | 0.4% conversion fee | Not possible |
What Starling Bank is Designed For
Starling provides a complete business current account, similar to a high‑street bank but without branches. It includes core banking features as standard, with no monthly fee, and is backed by full UK banking regulation.
Starling suits businesses that want stability, protection, and room to grow.
Key Characteristics of Starling Business
Free business current account
Full UK banking licence
FSCS protection on eligible deposits
Built‑in invoicing and spending categories
Overdrafts and business loans available
Available to sole traders and limited companies
Trade‑Offs to Consider
Fewer bundled admin or automation tools
Limited accounting software incentives
Less focused on micro-businesses
Starling is often chosen by established sole traders and SMEs that want a reliable, bank‑level solution.
What Mettle is Designed For
Mettle is built for very small operations and sole traders who want to keep things simple. Its standout feature is complimentary access to FreeAgent accounting software.
Rather than offering advanced banking features, Mettle focuses on helping busy entrepreneurs stay organised and tax‑ready.
Key Characteristics of Mettle
Free business account with no monthly fee
FSCS protection on eligible deposits
Free FreeAgent accounting software included
Simple app‑based money management
Backed by NatWest
Available to sole traders and small limited companies
Trade‑Offs to Consider
Not a fully licensed bank
No overdrafts, loans, or credit products
Limited advanced banking features
Mettle tends to appeal to freelancers and sole traders who want banking and accounting to work together.
How They Charge
Starling Pricing
No monthly account fee
No paid tiers or add‑ons
Charges apply for services like cash handling
Lending products priced separately
Starling Bank’s pricing is simple and transparent.
Mettle Pricing
Free account only
No subscription fees
Accounting software included at no extra cost
Charges apply for cash deposits
Mettle’s pricing suits businesses that want predictable, zero‑cost banking.
Feature Comparison: Starling vs Mettle
Everyday Banking
Payments and transfers: Both support Faster Payments and Direct Debits
Business debit cards: Both provide Mastercard business debit cards
Account access: Mobile apps with online account management
Invoicing and Admin
Starling: Built‑in invoicing included
Mettle: Relies on FreeAgent for invoicing and bookkeeping
Accounting Support
Starling: Integrates with accounting software
Mettle: FreeAgent included free of charge
Cash Handling
Starling: Cash deposits via the Post Office
Mettle: Cash deposits via the Post Office
Lending and Credit
Starling: Overdrafts and loans available
Mettle: No business loans or overdrafts
Regulation and Protection
Starling Bank and Mettle operate under different regulatory frameworks, which affect how customer funds are protected.
Starling is a fully licensed UK bank
The FSCS protects eligible deposits up to £120,000
Funds benefit from full UK banking regulation
Mettle operates as an E-Money Institution (EMI)
The FSCS protects eligible deposits up to £120,000
Money is held separately from Mettle’s own funds
For businesses where deposit protection is a priority, Starling Bank offers stronger regulatory reassurance.
Who Should Consider Starling?
Starling Business may be a good fit if your company:
Wants a fully licensed bank account
Might want an overdraft or lending options
Is growing beyond being a sole trader
Wants a traditional banking experience
Who Should Consider Mettle?
Mettle could suit businesses that:
Are sole traders or very small companies
Want free accounting software included
Prefer simplicity
Don’t need business finance solutions
Want a free, admin‑light option
Alternatives to Starling and Mettle
You may want to explore other business bank accounts if your company:
Needs advanced expense management
Trades internationally
Requires overdrafts but likes fintech tools
Wants the option of add‑ons or subscriptions
In those cases, it’s worth comparing other UK providers until you find a better fit.
Starling vs Mettle FAQs
Is Mettle cheaper than Starling?
For most sole traders, yes, but only by a small amount. Both accounts are free to run, and neither charges for UK transfers. Mettle is cheaper for cash deposits, at £2.75 per deposit against Starling’s 0.7% (minimum £3). Starling is cheaper for cash withdrawals, which are free at cash machines, compared with £1 at Mettle. If you send money abroad or need CHAPS, Mettle can’t do either, so the cheaper option is Starling.
Does Starling or Mettle charge for cash deposits?
Yes, both do. Starling charges 0.7% of each Post Office deposit, with a £3 minimum. Mettle charges a flat £2.75 per deposit but only accepts £10 to £500 at a time, up to £500 a day and £23,000 a year. If your business takes more cash than that, Starling is the more practical choice.
Is my money protected with Mettle?
Yes, if you have the Mettle bank account. The Mettle bank account is provided by National Westminster Bank plc, and eligible deposits are protected by the FSCS up to £120,000. Older Mettle e-money accounts aren’t covered by the FSCS. Mettle says you can tell which account you have from your sort code: a sort code beginning with 0 is the bank account, and one beginning with 2 is the older e-money account.
Can I get an overdraft with Starling or Mettle?
Only with Starling, and only if you’re a limited company or LLP. Starling offers arranged overdrafts on business accounts, subject to eligibility, with an annual fee of 1.75% of the limit (minimum £50) plus interest. Starling doesn’t offer arranged overdrafts on sole trader accounts, and Mettle doesn’t offer any credit. If you think you’ll need finance, it’s worth comparing business loans alongside your account.
Can I make international payments with Mettle?
You can receive them, but you can’t send them. Mettle charges £4 for incoming international payments over £10, plus 1.5% if the money needs converting to pounds. It doesn’t currently offer outbound international payments. Starling lets you send money abroad for a 0.4% conversion fee and offers a euro account for £2 a month.
Do Starling and Mettle include accounting software?
Yes, both now do. Mettle includes FreeAgent at no cost as long as you make at least one transaction a month from your account. Starling includes Accounting Essentials, its own bookkeeping tool with an HMRC-recognised Making Tax Digital for Income Tax feature, free with every business account. VAT-registered businesses can upgrade to Accounting Plus for £7 a month. Starling also connects to Xero, QuickBooks and FreeAgent. For more options, see our guide to business bank accounts with MTD software.
Can a limited company open a Mettle account?
Yes, if it has no more than two owners. Mettle is open to sole traders and limited companies with up to two owners, but only one owner can access the account. Starling accepts sole traders, limited companies and LLPs, and every director on the account gets full access.
Our Verdict: Starling vs Mettle
Mettle is the better pick for sole traders and very small limited companies that want free accounting software and pay in small amounts of cash. Starling is the better pick for limited companies that need an overdraft, send money abroad or handle larger volumes of cash.
Both accounts cost nothing a month, and both now protect eligible deposits up to £120,000 under the FSCS. The difference is in what each one will let you do.
Mettle wins on cost for low-volume cash businesses. A flat £2.75 per Post Office deposit beats Starling’s 0.7% (minimum £3) on every deposit Mettle accepts. FreeAgent is included as long as you make one transaction a month, which suits sole traders preparing for Making Tax Digital. The limits are tight, though. Mettle caps cash at £500 a day and £23,000 a year, can’t send international payments, doesn’t offer CHAPS and doesn’t lend.
Starling is the more complete business current account. Limited companies can apply for an arranged overdraft. You can send payments abroad for a 0.4% conversion fee and add a euro account for £2 a month. Since March 2026, Starling also includes free accounting and Making Tax Digital tools, so Mettle’s FreeAgent offer is less of a differentiator than it used to be.
In our experience, the deciding question is whether you’ll ever need to borrow or pay suppliers overseas. If you will, choose Starling. If you won’t, and your business is just you, Mettle is hard to beat on simplicity.