7 months ago

Mixed Signals Amidst HS2 Uncertainty

The fate of the High Speed 2 (HS2) rail project is now hanging in the balance amidst rising costs and Government indecision. The latest developments suggest that the Government might soon derail the Birmingham to Manchester section of HS2, a move that industry experts are dreading. In this article, we look at the finer details and the implications of a potential HS2 cancellation that could leave SMEs stranded.

All Aboard the HS2 Project

HS2 is an ambitious high-speed rail project designed to connect London, the Midlands and the North of England. The project is divided into several phases, with the first part linking West London to Birmingham, already under construction.

The scheme has been plagued by delays, excess costs and even route cuts. The entire eastern leg between Birmingham and Leeds was abandoned in 2021, a big letdown for many businesses in West Yorkshire.

Birmingham to Manchester Connection

The proposed cancellation of the Birmingham to Manchester section of HS2 has raised serious concerns among experts. Richard Bowker, the former head of the Strategic Rail Authority, labelled the move ‘very stupid’.

Man looking at train timesHe argues that this segment is fully integrated with the Northern Powerhouse Rail project, which aims to improve connectivity between Liverpool, Manchester and Leeds. The HS2 line from Manchester Airport to Piccadilly station is crucial in the grand plan. A change of plans could represent a spanner in the works for Northern Powerhouse Rail.

Impact on SMEs

HS2 has been touted as a project to stimulate economic growth, particularly in regions away from the capital. The rail link was expected to attract investment, create jobs and foster development in these areas. Cancelling of sections of HS2 could hinder this, affecting SMEs that rely on a vibrant economy.

Improved transport links like HS2 are vital for the development of SMEs in the UK. They provide easier access to markets, suppliers and customers, enabling businesses to expand their reach. A cancellation could leave SMEs in the affected regions struggling to compete on a national scale.

SMEs often play a crucial role in the supply chains of larger corporations, so a well-connected transport network is essential for smooth operations in many sectors. The uncertainty surrounding HS2 could disrupt these supply chains, affecting SMEs and large companies.

Government and Businesses Tracks Apart

Tom Wagner, co-owner of Birmingham City Football Club, has warned that abandoning the Birmingham to Manchester link could damage investor trust. He said: "Any deviation could result in a loss of investor trust and this would have a considerable negative impact on the UK. The ambitious HS2 project falls into this category."

Conservative MP for Tatton, Esther McVey, claimed that cancelling would be the ‘right thing to do’. She said: "Things have significantly changed since lockdown and people would now sooner jump on a Zoom to save time and money.”

End of the Line?

The fate of HS2 is far from certain, and the impact of its cancellation is a big concern for SMEs. While cost control is a legitimate consideration, you can't ignore the broader consequences for economic growth, connectivity and investor confidence.

As an integral component of the UK's economy, smaller businesses may navigate trying times if this rail project falls by the wayside. As difficult decisions loom, the Government must weigh the pros and cons of its choices carefully, keeping the long-term interests of the economy in mind.

Next Stop: Alternative Funding

If your business’s investment prospects have been affected by recent HS2 news, alternatives are available. At BusinessComparison, we provide expert assistance in identifying suitable finance options for your business. Our comprehensive comparison includes a range of business loans from reputable high-street banks and more specialised small lenders.

Let us Help Your Business

We help you compare essential business products and services, ensuring you get the best deal and helping you with your bottom line. Save time and money with us by comparing today.

Business Loans icon

Business Bank Accounts icon

Invoice Finance icon

Business Energy icon

Business Broadband icon

Card Machines icon

Business Credit Cards icon

Business Insurance icon

Leased Lines icon


Sam White