Octopus Energy and Scottish Power both supply gas and electricity to UK businesses, but they sell it in very different ways. Octopus Energy for Business is the business arm of the UK's largest household supplier and says it powers over 100,000 businesses.
Scottish Power is owned by Spain's Iberdrola and, since it stopped selling to industrial and commercial customers in 2022, has focused on small and medium-sized businesses.
The biggest practical difference is how you buy. Octopus only sells direct and isn't available through brokers or comparison sites, including ours. Scottish Power sells direct and through intermediaries.
TLDR: Octopus is the better choice for low-usage electricity sites, businesses that value service, and anyone who wants 100% carbon-free electricity and smart time-of-use tariffs as standard. Scottish Power was cheaper for electricity above about 12,500 kWh a year and for most gas users in our data, and its Advantage for Business tariff lets you lock in lower prices if the market falls. But Scottish Power's deemed rates are far harsher.
We built this comparison from each supplier's own published documents, including Octopus's live business tariff prices (which we pulled in November 2026), Scottish Power's October 2026 price sheets, our own quote data, Citizens Advice and Trustpilot. If you already know your usage, you can go straight to our business energy comparison.
The Short Answer: Octopus or Scottish Power?
It depends mainly on how much electricity you use and how you like to buy:
Under about 12,500 kWh of electricity a year: Octopus's published 24-month fixed prices undercut Scottish Power's average quote at every usage level we tested, mostly because Octopus's standing charge is less than half as high.
Above about 12,500 kWh a year: Scottish Power's lower average unit rate (27.0p/kWh) wins, and the gap widens as usage rises.
Gas: Scottish Power was cheaper for most gas users we modelled. Octopus's 24-month fix only came out ahead below about 7,000 kWh a year.
Service: Octopus ranks 4th of 15 on Citizens Advice's business complaints table. Scottish Power ranks 7th, with a complaints score about twice as high.
If you forget to renew: Octopus's out-of-contract prices sit close to its fixed prices. Scottish Power's deemed electricity rates average 35.6p/kWh and 254p a day, a 39% premium on its average quote for a micro business.
Octopus vs Scottish Power at a Glance
Feature | Octopus Energy for Business | Scottish Power |
|---|---|---|
Parent company | Octopus Energy Group | Iberdrola |
Business size focus | Sole traders to large businesses (1GWh to 10GWh) | Micro, small and medium businesses; left the I&C market in 2022 |
Gas | Yes | Yes |
Electricity | Yes | Yes |
How you buy | Direct only; no brokers or comparison sites | Direct, through brokers and comparison sites |
Fixed contracts | 12 or 24 months for SMEs | 1, 2 or 3 years |
What's fixed | Unit rate and standing charge for the full term | Energy cost fixed; network, social and environmental costs reviewed quarterly |
Standard electricity | 100% carbon-free on business tariffs | Standard mix on For Business; 100% renewable on Advantage for Business and Renewable for Business |
Smart time-of-use tariffs | Shape Shifters: Trio and Agile | Not offered for business |
No standing charge option | Yes, for Bands 2 to 4 | No |
Average electricity price | 30.6p/kWh and 68.0p a day (12-month fix, Band 2, published 16 November 2026) | 27.0p/kWh and 141.8p a day (our average quote, October 2026) |
Average gas price | 11.1p/kWh and 14.1p a day (12-month fix) | 8.8p/kWh and 31.1p a day (our average quote, October 2026) |
Deemed electricity rate | Matches its variable rate: 33.4p/kWh and 68.3p a day on average | 34.9p to 37.4p/kWh and 234p to 291p a day |
Citizens Advice business complaints (April to June 2026) | 4th of 15, score 135.0 | 7th of 15, score 283.0 |
Citizens Advice star rating (April to June 2026) | 3.67 out of 5, 5th | 2.76 out of 5, 12th |
Trustpilot (November 2026) | 4.8 from 909,090 reviews | 4.4 from 215,220 reviews |
Which Supplier Offers Better Tariffs?
Octopus is the only one of the two that publishes its business prices openly. Its fixed tariffs for small businesses are listed on its public tariff system, by region and by electricity band, so anyone can check them. Scottish Power, like most business suppliers, doesn't publish fixed prices for new customers. Your quote depends on:
Business location and network region
Annual consumption
Meter type, including whether you have a smart or half-hourly meter
Contract length
Payment method
Credit profile
What Is Octopus's Electricity Band, and Why Does It Matter?
Octopus prices business electricity by band. According to its business electricity band guide, non-half-hourly sites fall into one of four bands, set by Ofgem, based on annual use:
Band | Annual electricity use |
|---|---|
Band 1 | 0 to 3,571 kWh |
Band 2 | 3,572 to 12,553 kWh |
Band 3 | 12,554 to 25,279 kWh |
Band 4 | 25,280 kWh and above |
Octopus keeps the same standing charge across all four bands and varies the unit rate instead. When we looked at its 16 November 2026 prices, Band 2 had the lowest unit rate and Band 4 the highest. That matters for one reason: a business near the top of a band pays the same unit rate as one near the bottom, so where you sit inside your band affects how good the deal is.
Octopus Tariffs
12-Month and 24-Month Fixed
Octopus's standard business tariffs fix both the unit rate and standing charge for the term, with 100% carbon-free electricity included. On the version that went on sale on 16 November 2026, its public tariff data showed no exit fee on either term. The business terms (clause 11.2) still allow Octopus to recover reasonable costs if you end a fixed contract early, so check your Supply Summary.
One detail stood out when we ran the numbers: the 24-month fix was cheaper than the 12-month fix in all four bands, by between 2.2p and 3.2p/kWh on average for electricity and 1.4p/kWh for gas. Longer fixes usually cost more, so this suggests the wholesale market expects prices to ease.
Best for:
Small businesses that want budget certainty with no quarterly cost adjustments
Businesses that prefer to buy direct and see the price before speaking to anyone
No Standing Charge Fixed
A 12-month fix with a 0p daily standing charge and a higher unit rate, open to Bands 2, 3 and 4. Octopus describes it as a trial and says businesses at the lower end of their band are most likely to save.
Best for:
Low-usage gas supplies (see our analysis below)
Sites where you'd rather pay nothing in months when you use nothing
Shape Shifters: Trio
A 12-month time-of-use tariff with three fixed rates: a night rate (midnight to 7am), a day rate, and a 4pm to 7pm peak rate. On 16 November 2026, the average rates across all 14 regions were 25.5p (night), 28.0p (day) and 53.8p (peak), with a 68.0p daily standing charge.
Best for:
Offices, shops and workshops that close by 4pm or can cut use in the early evening
Shape Shifters: Agile and Export
Agile follows the wholesale market, with prices changing every half-hour, and Octopus says the unit rate will never go above £1. Shape Shifters: Export does the same for electricity you sell back to the grid.
Best for:
Businesses with batteries, solar panels or EV fleets that can move demand around
Solar, Export and Big Business Options
Octopus also offers Panel Power (a solar export tariff), Electric Match (which shares solar generation across a business's sites) and big business contracts for sites using between 1GWh and 10GWh a year, with trading up to three years ahead.
Best for:
Multi-site businesses with on-site generation
Larger users who want to buy in stages
Scottish Power Tariffs
Advantage for Business
Scottish Power's newest tariff is a 1, 2 or 3-year fix sold only direct, with 100% renewable electricity as standard, according to its Advantage for Business page. In the last 12 months of your contract, Scottish Power alerts you by text or email if prices drop. You can then blend your current rate with the new lower rate and extend, lock in a lower price to start when your contract ends, or wait.
Best for:
Businesses worried about fixing at the top of the market
Owners happy to manage their account online
For Business and Renewable for Business
Both run for 1, 2 or 3 years. The energy cost is fixed, but network, social and environmental costs are reviewed quarterly and can change on 1 January, April, July and October. Renewable for Business matches your electricity with REGOs from Scottish Power's own UK wind farms. Its terms (clause 9.2) say renewable charges are added to your invoices.
Best for:
Businesses that want a longer fix than Octopus offers
Businesses buying through a broker
Standard Variable and Deemed
Standard Variable applies if your contract ends and you don't choose another tariff. Deemed rates apply if you move into a site Scottish Power supplies without agreeing a contract. Both are published by region (see the deemed rates section below).
Tariff Comparison Table
Tariff Type | Octopus | Scottish Power |
|---|---|---|
Fixed rate | 12 or 24 months | 1, 2 or 3 years |
Fully fixed (non-energy costs included) | Yes | No, non-energy costs reviewed quarterly |
Price-drop protection | No | Yes, Advantage for Business |
100% renewable or carbon-free electricity | Standard on all business tariffs | Advantage for Business and Renewable for Business |
No standing charge | Yes, Bands 2 to 4 | No |
Time-of-use | Shape Shifters: Trio | No |
Wholesale-linked | Shape Shifters: Agile | No |
Export tariffs | Shape Shifters: Export, Panel Power | No business export tariff advertised |
Sold through brokers | No | Yes |
Large business contracts | 1GWh to 10GWh | No longer sold |
Winner: Octopus for range and transparency. Scottish Power for longer fixes and its price-drop feature.
How Do Contract Lengths Compare?
Octopus Contract Terms
Contract Type | Typical Length |
|---|---|
Fixed (standard) | 12 or 24 months |
No Standing Charge fixed | 12 months |
Shape Shifters: Trio | 12 months |
Shape Shifters: Agile | Rolling |
Flexible (variable and out-of-contract) | No fixed term |
Big business | Up to 3 years ahead |
Scottish Power Contract Terms
Contract Type | Typical Length |
|---|---|
Advantage for Business | 1, 2 or 3 years |
For Business | 1, 2 or 3 years |
Renewable for Business | 1, 2 or 3 years |
Standard Variable | No fixed term |
Deemed | No fixed term until you agree a contract |
Contract Length Scorecard
Factor | Octopus | Scottish Power |
|---|---|---|
Longest SME fix | 24 months | 3 years |
Price certainty during the term | Full: unit rate and standing charge fixed | Partial: non-energy costs move quarterly |
Renewal | Written reminder before your end date (clause 3.4) | Letter about 60 days before your end date (clause 6.2); offers from 12 months out on Advantage |
What happens if you don't renew | Moves to Flexible, priced close to fixed rates | Moves to Standard Variable |
Early exit | No exit fee listed on current fixes; reasonable costs can be recovered | No set fee; Scottish Power can object to a switch before your contract ends (clause 10.4) |
What Do Deemed and Out-of-Contract Rates Look Like?
This is where the two suppliers differ most. Octopus says in its pricing principles that its deemed rates match its standard variable rates.
Scottish Power publishes separate deemed electricity and gas prices, effective from October 2026, which are higher than its Standard Variable electricity prices.
Rate | Octopus Flexible | SP Standard Variable | SP Deemed |
|---|---|---|---|
Electricity unit rate | 33.4p/kWh | 29.6p/kWh | 35.6p/kWh |
Electricity standing charge | 68.3p a day | 160.3p a day | 254.3p a day |
Gas unit rate | 9.2p/kWh | Not checked | 11.7p/kWh |
Gas standing charge | 15.0p a day | Not checked | 225.0p a day |
All prices exclude VAT. Scottish Power's electricity prices also exclude CCL.
When we compared each region line by line, Scottish Power's deemed electricity price was exactly 6p/kWh and 94p a day higher than its own Direct Debit Standard Variable price in every region. Its deemed price matches its cash or cheque Standard Variable price plus 1p/kWh, so moving in without a contract effectively puts you on its most expensive payment method.
Here's what that means in pounds for a business using 10,000 kWh of electricity a year:
Scenario | Annual cost (ex VAT and CCL) | Premium over a fixed deal |
|---|---|---|
Octopus 12-month fix (Band 2) | £3,308 | |
Octopus Flexible (out of contract) | £3,592 | +£284 (9%) |
Scottish Power average quote (October 2026) | £3,218 | |
Scottish Power Standard Variable (Direct Debit) | £3,541 | +£323 (10%) |
Scottish Power deemed | £4,484 | +£1,267 (39%) |
And one finding we didn't expect: on 16 November 2026, Octopus's Flexible business gas (9.2p/kWh and 15.0p a day) was cheaper than its own 12-month fixed gas (11.1p/kWh and 14.1p a day) in all 14 regions, by 1.6p to 1.9p/kWh. Flexible prices can change, with 30 days' notice under clause 9.3.8 of the terms, but for now an Octopus gas customer who drifts out of contract isn't penalised.
Under Ofgem's rules for microbusinesses, a supplier can't ask for more than 30 days' notice to end a contract once your fixed term is up. In our experience, the businesses that lose most money are those that move into premises and don't call the supplier for weeks.
Our deemed contract energy rates guide explains how to avoid this.
Octopus vs Scottish Power Pricing Structure
Every quote from either supplier is made up of a unit rate, a standing charge, non-energy (pass-through) costs, any broker commission, VAT and the Climate Change Levy.
What Do the Two Suppliers Charge?
We've used two snapshots. For Scottish Power, these are the average rates quoted in October 2026, from our average business energy prices guide.
Octopus doesn't appear in that data because it doesn't quote through comparison sites, so we took the prices it publishes for its business tariffs that went on sale in November 2026, averaged across all 14 regions.
Tariff | Elec unit rate | Elec standing charge | Gas unit rate | Gas standing charge |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Scottish Power (average quote, October 2026) | 27.0p/kWh | 141.8p a day | 8.8p/kWh | 31.1p a day |
Octopus 12-month fixed, Band 1 | 32.2p/kWh | 68.0p a day | 11.1p/kWh | 14.1p a day |
Octopus 12-month fixed, Band 2 | 30.6p/kWh | 68.0p a day | 11.1p/kWh | 14.1p a day |
Octopus 12-month fixed, Band 3 | 31.6p/kWh | 68.0p a day | 11.1p/kWh | 14.1p a day |
Octopus 12-month fixed, Band 4 | 32.7p/kWh | 68.0p a day | 11.1p/kWh | 14.1p a day |
Octopus 24-month fixed, Band 2 | 28.1p/kWh | 72.4p a day | 9.7p/kWh | 14.5p a day |
Octopus No Standing Charge, Band 2 | 41.1p/kWh | 0p | 11.6p/kWh | 0p |
Excludes VAT and CCL. Octopus regional ranges: 12-month Band 2 electricity from 29.8p/kWh (Southern) to 32.5p/kWh (Merseyside and North Wales); standing charges from 51.0p a day (London) to 80.6p a day (Merseyside and North Wales).
Applied to typical usage, those prices give the following annual costs:
Usage | Scottish Power | Octopus 12-month | Octopus 24-month |
|---|---|---|---|
3,000 kWh electricity | £1,328 | £1,215 | £1,134 |
10,000 kWh electricity | £3,218 | £3,308 | £3,077 |
20,000 kWh electricity | £5,918 | £6,574 | £6,128 |
40,000 kWh electricity | £11,318 | £13,312 | £12,456 |
5,000 kWh gas | £554 | £605 | £537 |
10,000 kWh gas | £994 | £1,158 | £1,021 |
22,500 kWh gas | £2,094 | £2,542 | £2,231 |
47,500 kWh gas | £4,294 | £5,310 | £4,651 |
Illustrative only. Based on averages, not your quote. Excludes VAT and CCL.
Where Is the Break-Even Point?
The two suppliers have opposite pricing shapes. Scottish Power's average quote had a low unit rate and a high standing charge (£518 a year before you use anything). Octopus has a higher unit rate and a standing charge less than half the size (£248 a year on a 12-month fix).
So Octopus wins at low usage and Scottish Power wins at high usage. We worked out exactly where the line falls:
Octopus tariff | Octopus is cheaper below |
|---|---|
12-month fix, Band 1 | Whole band (up to 3,571 kWh) |
12-month fix, Band 2 | About 7,500 kWh |
12-month fix, Bands 3 and 4 | Never within the band |
24-month fix, Bands 1 and 2 | Whole band (up to 12,553 kWh) |
24-month fix, Bands 3 and 4 | Never within the band |
12-month gas fix | About 2,700 kWh |
24-month gas fix | About 6,900 kWh |
Flexible gas | About 14,700 kWh |
The useful rule of thumb: if you use less than about 12,500 kWh of electricity a year and you're happy with a two-year fix, Octopus's published price beat Scottish Power's average quote. Above that, Scottish Power's average was lower.
Two caveats matter. These are averages taken five weeks apart, and wholesale prices move. And Scottish Power's quotes can vary a lot by region and by business, while Octopus's published price is what every business in that band and region pays. Use this as a guide to which supplier to quote first, not as your answer.
Is the Octopus No Standing Charge Tariff Worth It?
For electricity, not at current prices. We compared the No Standing Charge rate against the standard 12-month fix in each of the 14 regions. The highest break-even point we found was 2,547 kWh a year (North Scotland). Band 2, the lowest band that can join, starts at 3,572 kWh. So on 16 November 2026 prices, every eligible business would pay less on the standard 12-month fix with the standing charge.
Gas is different. The No Standing Charge gas rate (11.6p/kWh) beats the standard 12-month gas fix below about 9,700 kWh a year. That suits a café with a small gas hob or a unit with gas heating that's rarely on.
Is Shape Shifters: Trio Cheaper Than a Standard Fix?
Only if you can keep your use out of the 4pm to 7pm peak. Assuming 10% of your electricity is used overnight, our calculations show Trio beats Octopus's standard 12-month fix when less than about 15% of your use falls in the peak window (Band 3) or less than 11% (Band 2). A business using 20,000 kWh a year with 5% of its use in the peak would pay about £6,058 on Trio against £6,574 on the standard fix, a saving of around £516.
Unit Rate
The price per kWh you use. Scottish Power's average quoted electricity unit rate (27.0p) was 3.6p lower than Octopus's cheapest 12-month band. Its gas unit rate (8.8p) was 2.3p lower.
Standing Charge
The fixed daily charge, paid whatever you use. Scottish Power's average electricity standing charge of 141.8p a day makes up 39% of the annual bill for a site using 3,000 kWh. Low-usage sites such as storage units, kiosks and small offices should look at this before the unit rate.
Pass-Through Charges
Non-energy costs include network charges, balancing costs, government schemes and metering. Octopus fixes these for the term. On Scottish Power's For Business tariffs, they're updated quarterly using published indices (clause 13.1.2), so your bill can rise during a fixed contract.
Our guide to pass-through vs fully fixed energy contracts explains the difference.
Advance Payments and Credit Checks
Octopus says it doesn't refuse businesses based on their size, sector or credit score, and uses a security deposit instead. Its terms (clause 7.3.4) let it ask for a higher payment on account if your credit risk worsens, payable within seven days. Scottish Power can ask for a deposit before supply starts (clause 13.6), and for limited companies its terms (clause 13.17) make the signing director jointly liable and allow it to ask for a personal guarantee capped at the previous quarter's usage.
VAT
Most businesses pay VAT at 20% on energy. A reduced rate of 5% applies if you use no more than 33 kWh of electricity or 145 kWh of gas a day on average, according to HMRC's guidance on VAT on fuel and power. Sites under these thresholds are also exempt from the Climate Change Levy.
Pricing Transparency Comparison
Area | Octopus | Scottish Power |
|---|---|---|
Fixed prices published | Yes, by band and region | No |
Online quote | Yes, in about a minute | Yes, through its sales site |
Deemed rates published | Yes, matches Flexible | Yes, by region |
Variable rates published | Yes | Yes, by region and payment method |
Non-energy costs fixed | Yes | No, reviewed quarterly |
Winner: Octopus for transparency and lower standing charges. Scottish Power on price for higher electricity and gas users in our data.
Which Supplier Has Better Green Credentials?
Octopus Sustainability Initiatives
Offers:
100% carbon-free electricity on all business tariffs
Shape Shifters tariffs that reward using power when the grid is cleaner
Electric Match for sharing on-site solar across sites
Octopus Fleet for business EV charging and a staff EV salary sacrifice scheme
Plots for Kilowatts, which leases spare business land to renewable projects
Pros:
Supplier-wide mix of 86.4% renewable and 13.6% nuclear in April 2024 to March 2025, with zero reported CO2 emissions
Carbon-free electricity included at no extra cost
Cons:
"Carbon-free" includes nuclear, so it isn't 100% renewable
No green gas option advertised for SMEs
Scottish Power Sustainability Initiatives
Offers:
100% renewable electricity on Advantage for Business and Renewable for Business, matched with REGOs from its own UK wind farms
Free business smart meters
EV charging, solar panels, batteries and heat pumps for businesses
A Green Energy Solutions Guide produced with the Carbon Trust
Pros:
Renewable claims backed by its own UK generation and described as GHG Protocol Scope 2 compliant
Renewable electricity included as standard on Advantage for Business
Cons:
Supplier-wide mix was only 7% renewable, with 70% gas and 14% coal, in April 2024 to March 2025, according to Scottish Power's fuel mix disclosure
The standard For Business tariff doesn't include renewable electricity, and renewable charges are added on Renewable for Business
Why Is Scottish Power Fuel Mix Low When It Owns Wind Farms?
Because generation and supply are counted separately. Scottish Power allocates the renewable certificates from its wind farms to its green tariffs. Customers on its other tariffs get what's left, which in 2024/25 was 73% gas, 14% coal and just 3% renewable.
If renewable electricity matters for your reporting, check the tariff, not the brand. The UK average that year was 42.1% renewable.
Sustainability Comparison
Renewable Category | Octopus | Scottish Power |
|---|---|---|
Supplier-wide renewable share (2024/25) | 86.4% | 7% |
Supplier-wide CO2 emissions (2024/25) | 0g/kWh | 450g/kWh |
Standard SME electricity product | 100% carbon-free | Standard mix (For Business) |
100% renewable option | Not separately offered | Advantage for Business, Renewable for Business |
Own renewable generation | Yes, through Octopus Energy Generation | Yes, UK wind farms |
Time-of-use and export tariffs | Yes | No |
EV, solar and heat pumps | EV fleet charging, solar export | EV charging, solar, batteries, heat pumps |
Winner: Octopus on supplier-wide figures and standard tariffs. Scottish Power if you specifically want REGO-backed renewable electricity from named UK wind farms.
Customer Service Comparison
We've used three measures: the Citizens Advice non-domestic complaints table, which ranks business suppliers by weighted complaints per 10,000 customers, the Citizens Advice star rating, which mostly reflects household service, and Trustpilot.
Octopus Support
Strengths:
4th of 15 in the Citizens Advice business complaints table for April to June 2026, with a score of 135.0, improved from 138.4 in January to March
3.67 out of 5 in the star rating, 5th of 16, with 5 out of 5 for customer commitments
4.8 out of 5 on Trustpilot from 909,090 reviews, with 97% of negative reviews answered
Weaknesses:
3.4 out of 5 for billing and metering in the star rating
Recent Trustpilot complaints mention estimated bills, appointment scheduling and slow fixes for complex meter problems
Scottish Power Support
Strengths:
4.0 out of 5 for contact waiting time in the star rating, its best score
Its business complaints score improved from 301.2 to 283.0 between January to March and April to June 2026
4.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot from 215,220 reviews
Weaknesses:
7th of 15 on the business complaints table, with a score more than twice Octopus's
2.76 out of 5 in the star rating, 12th of 16, with 1.0 out of 5 for fewer complaints
18% of its Trustpilot reviews are 1-star, against 3% for Octopus
Which?'s 2026 survey placed it last of 17 suppliers
Customer Service Scorecard
Area | Octopus | Scottish Power |
|---|---|---|
Citizens Advice business complaints (April to June 2026) | 4th, score 135.0 | 7th, score 283.0 |
Citizens Advice star rating (April to June 2026) | 3.67, 5th | 2.76, 12th |
Fewer complaints score | 3.5 | 1.0 |
Contact waiting time score | 3.6 | 4.0 |
Billing and metering score | 3.4 | 2.8 |
Trustpilot (November 2026) | 4.8 from 909,090 reviews | 4.4 from 215,220 reviews |
1-star Trustpilot reviews | 3% | 18% |
Both Trustpilot profiles mix household and business reviews and both companies invite customers to review, so treat these scores with caution. The Citizens Advice business table is the more relevant measure, and on that Octopus has a clear lead. Scottish Power did score higher for contact waiting time, though.
How Do Smart Meters and Tech Compare?
Octopus Technology Solutions
Online account and app built on Octopus's own Kraken platform
Shape Shifters: Trio, Agile and Export, which use smart meter data
Half-hourly data for carbon reporting
Electric Match and Panel Power for solar sites
Octopus Fleet, with access to 1.4 million public charge points
Ideal for: businesses with smart meters that can move when they use power, and those with solar, batteries or EVs.
Scottish Power Technology Solutions
Free smart meter installation, bookable online
Daily readings as standard, with half-hourly data stored for up to two years (clause 4.5)
Online account with daily renewal offers on Advantage for Business
EV charging, solar, battery and heat pump installation
Ideal for: businesses that want a smart meter and installation services from their supplier, without changing how they use energy.
Technology Comparison
Feature | Octopus | Scottish Power |
|---|---|---|
Smart meters | Yes | Free, bookable online |
Time-of-use tariffs | Trio and Agile | No |
Export tariffs | Yes | Not advertised for business |
Renewal alerts when prices fall | No | Yes, Advantage for Business |
EV | Fleet charging card and salary sacrifice | Charge point installation |
Solar, battery and heat pumps | Export tariffs and solar sharing | Installation |
Winner: Octopus for smart tariffs. Scottish Power for installation services.
Business Energy Charges
Fee Type | Octopus | Scottish Power |
|---|---|---|
Standing charge | 68.0p a day electricity, 14.1p a day gas (12-month fix average) | 141.8p a day electricity, 31.1p a day gas (October 2026 average quote) |
Exit fees | None listed on current fixes; reasonable costs recoverable under clause 11.2 | No set fee; can object to a switch before your contract ends |
Non-energy cost changes | None during fixed term | Quarterly, on 1 January, April, July and October |
Non-Direct Debit payment | May cost more (clause 8.6) | Cash or cheque Standard Variable costs 5p/kWh and 94p a day more |
Late payment | Bank of England base rate plus 4% (clause 8.7.2) | RBS base rate plus 4% (clause 13.16) |
Security | Security deposit instead of refusing on credit | Deposit and possible director's personal guarantee |
Out-of-contract rates | Flexible: 33.4p/kWh and 68.3p a day | Standard Variable: 29.6p/kWh and 160.3p a day (Direct Debit) |
Deemed rates (electricity) | Same as Flexible | 35.6p/kWh and 254.3p a day on average |
Scottish Power's biggest hidden cost is its deemed rate if you take over premises without a contract, and the quarterly non-energy adjustments on its standard fixes. Octopus's biggest catch is that you can't compare it alongside other suppliers on a comparison site, so you need to get its price separately and check it against the market yourself.
Pros and Cons of Octopus
Advantages
Low standing charges. 68.0p a day on electricity and 14.1p on gas, less than half Scottish Power's average.
Published prices. You can see the price for your band and region before you speak to anyone.
Fully fixed. Non-energy costs don't move during the term.
Strong service record. 4th on the business complaints table and 4.8 on Trustpilot.
Mild out-of-contract prices. Flexible electricity was only about 9% above its 12-month fix for a 10,000 kWh site.
Smart tariffs. Trio, Agile and Export reward flexible businesses.
Disadvantages
Higher unit rates. Its cheapest 12-month electricity band was 3.6p/kWh above Scottish Power's average quote.
Shorter fixes. 24 months maximum for SMEs.
No broker or comparison site access. You have to quote direct.
No Standing Charge electricity doesn't pay at current prices. Every eligible business would pay less on the standard fix.
Pros and Cons of Scottish Power
Advantages
Lower average unit rates. 27.0p/kWh electricity and 8.8p/kWh gas in our October 2026 data.
Cheaper for higher users. Beat Octopus's published prices above about 12,500 kWh of electricity and 7,000 kWh of gas.
Up to 3-year fixes. Longer than Octopus offers small businesses.
Price-drop protection. Advantage for Business lets you blend in lower prices during your last 12 months.
REGO-backed renewable electricity from its own UK wind farms on two tariffs.
Disadvantages
High standing charges. 141.8p a day on average, which hurts low-usage sites.
Expensive deemed rates. 39% above its average quote for a 10,000 kWh site.
Partly fixed. Non-energy costs can change every quarter on For Business tariffs.
Weaker complaints record. 7th of 15, and 12th of 16 in the star rating.
No large business contracts. It no longer sells to industrial and commercial users.
Which Supplier Is Better for Which Business Types?
Business Type | Recommended | Reason |
|---|---|---|
Sole traders and micro sites under 3,571 kWh | Octopus | Lower standing charge wins at every usage level in Band 1 |
Small offices and shops using 3,572 to 12,553 kWh | Octopus (24-month fix) | Beat Scottish Power's average across the whole of Band 2 |
Shops, salons and offices using more than 12,500 kWh | Scottish Power | Lower average unit rate wins above Band 2 |
Restaurants, pubs and cafés with heavy gas use | Scottish Power | Lower gas unit rate; see our best energy suppliers for small businesses |
Sites with a small or occasional gas supply | Octopus | 14.1p a day gas standing charge, or No Standing Charge gas below about 9,700 kWh |
Businesses that close before 4pm | Octopus | Shape Shifters: Trio |
Businesses with solar, batteries or EVs | Octopus | Agile, Export and Electric Match |
Businesses wanting a 3-year fix | Scottish Power | Octopus fixes for a maximum of 24 months |
Businesses that want named UK wind REGOs for Scope 2 | Scottish Power | Advantage for Business and Renewable for Business |
Businesses moving into new premises | Octopus | Deemed rates match its Flexible rates |
Users above 1GWh | Octopus | Scottish Power no longer offers large business contracts |
Businesses that want to compare through a broker | Scottish Power | Octopus only sells direct |
Octopus vs Scottish Power: Side-by-Side
Category | Winner |
|---|---|
Tariff range | Octopus |
Electricity price, under about 12,500 kWh | Octopus |
Electricity price, above about 12,500 kWh | Scottish Power |
Gas price, most users | Scottish Power |
Contract length options | Scottish Power |
Price certainty during the term | Octopus |
Deemed and out-of-contract rates | Octopus |
Renewable credentials | Octopus |
Business complaints record | Octopus |
Smart tariffs and tech | Octopus |
Octopus wins seven categories and Scottish Power three, but price is the one most businesses weigh most heavily, and on price the answer depends on your usage.
Key Questions to Ask Before Deciding
How much electricity and gas did you use in the past 12 months, and which Octopus band does that put you in?
What's the full annual cost at your usage, including the standing charge?
Are non-energy costs fixed for the term, or reviewed quarterly?
Is the electricity 100% renewable, carbon-free (including nuclear), or the standard mix?
How much of your electricity do you use between 4pm and 7pm?
What happens on the day your contract ends, and what rate applies?
Are you moving into new premises, and who supplies them now?
If you're quoting through a broker, how much commission is included?
Will the supplier ask for a deposit or a director's guarantee?
Can you escalate complaints to the Energy Ombudsman?
Octopus vs Scottish Power FAQs
Is Octopus or Scottish Power cheaper for business energy?
Octopus was cheaper for electricity below about 12,500 kWh a year on its 24-month fix, because its standing charge is less than half Scottish Power's average. Scottish Power was cheaper above that, and for most gas users, because of its lower unit rates.
Can I compare Octopus business energy on a comparison site?
No. Octopus only sells direct and doesn't work with brokers or comparison sites. Get a quote from Octopus's website, then compare it with quotes from Scottish Power and other suppliers through our business energy comparison.
Is Scottish Power business electricity renewable?
Only on Advantage for Business and Renewable for Business, which are matched 100% with REGOs from Scottish Power's own UK wind farms. Its standard For Business tariff uses the standard mix, and its supplier-wide mix was 7% renewable in 2024/25.
Is Octopus business electricity 100% renewable?
Not quite. Octopus business tariffs are 100% carbon-free, which includes nuclear. Its supplier-wide mix was 86.4% renewable and 13.6% nuclear in 2024/25.
Which has better customer service, Octopus or Scottish Power?
Octopus. It ranked 4th of 15 on the Citizens Advice business complaints table for April to June 2026, against Scottish Power's 7th, and scored 3.67 out of 5 in the star rating against Scottish Power's 2.76. Scottish Power scored higher for contact waiting time.
Do Octopus and Scottish Power charge exit fees?
Neither lists a fixed exit fee for its current business fixes. Octopus can recover reasonable costs if you end a fixed contract early, and Scottish Power can object to a switch until your contract ends.
What happens when my contract ends?
With Octopus, you move to its Flexible tariff, which was about 9% dearer than its 12-month fix for electricity and cheaper than it for gas in November 2026. With Scottish Power, you move to its Standard Variable tariff, which was about 10% above its average quote for a 10,000 kWh electricity user.
What is Octopus's No Standing Charge tariff?
A 12-month fix with no daily standing charge and a higher unit rate, for businesses in electricity Bands 2 to 4. At 16 November 2026 prices, the electricity version cost more than the standard fix for every eligible business, but the gas version was cheaper below about 9,700 kWh a year.
Can large businesses use Octopus or Scottish Power?
Octopus offers big business contracts for sites using 1GWh to 10GWh a year. Scottish Power stopped selling to industrial and commercial customers in 2022 and now focuses on small and medium businesses.
Alternatives to Octopus and Scottish Power
Verdict: Octopus or Scottish Power?
Choose Octopus if you want:
The lowest cost for a low-usage electricity site, especially under 12,500 kWh a year
A low gas standing charge for a small or occasional gas supply
Fully fixed prices with no quarterly adjustments
Smart tariffs that reward using less power between 4pm and 7pm
A stronger complaints record and gentler out-of-contract prices
Choose Scottish Power if you want:
Lower unit rates for higher electricity or gas usage
A fixed contract of up to three years
The option to lock in lower prices if the market falls before your renewal
REGO-backed renewable electricity from named UK wind farms
To compare and buy through a broker or comparison service
For most micro businesses and low-usage sites, Octopus is the stronger choice. Its low standing charges, published prices and service record make it hard to beat below about 12,500 kWh of electricity a year. For busier sites, and especially those with heavy gas use, Scottish Power's lower unit rates made it the cheaper option in our data, as long as you renew on time.
Because Octopus only sells direct, the best way to choose is to get its published price for your band and region, then compare it against live quotes from Scottish Power and the rest of the market. You can compare business electricity and business gas prices in one go.